myHanse.com - Hanse Yacht Owners Website myHanse.com - Hanse Yacht Owners Website myHanse.com - Hanse Yacht Owners Website myHanse.com - Hanse Yacht Owners Website

Welcome to myHanse.com the forum for Hanse Yachts owners throughout the world.

  Active TopicsActive Topics  Display List of Forum MembersMemberlist  CalendarCalendar  Search The ForumSearch  HelpHelp
  RegisterRegister  LoginLogin
320
 myHanse - Hanse Yachts Owners Forum : Hints and Tips : 320
Message Icon Topic: Charging batteries Post Reply Post New Topic
Page  of 2 Next >>
Author Message
Raptor
Lieutenant Commander
Lieutenant Commander


Joined: 28 August 2009
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 66
Quote Raptor Replybullet Topic: Charging batteries
    Posted: 28 December 2009 at 09:45

I'm a new 320 Hanse owner and have limited experience with the electrical system onboard. My question is how do you charge the batteries (especially the small battery for starting the engine) when you are connected with shore cable? I have noticed from the instrument panel that the capacity on the start battery is getting lower. Tried to run the engine for an hour with no readable effect on the instrument panel. There is a charger installed onboard and would think that when you are connected to shore, the batteries will automatically be recharged. I would like to avoid removing the battery for recharging. Comments appreciated.

IP IP Logged
fiddler
Sub Lieutenant
Sub Lieutenant
Avatar

Joined: 01 November 2007
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 18
Quote fiddler Replybullet Posted: 28 December 2009 at 19:05
Both batteries are supposed to charge on shore power as well as when the engine is running,  so something is not right here.  I would put a voltmeter directly on each battery in turn when they should be charging,  and it should show a figure well in excess of 12.7 volts (probably 13.0 or more).   If it is less than that,  there is a problem in the charging circuit.  Otherwise,  one or both batteries is not holding charge and will need replacing.

Assuming that you haven't got a huge power eater permanently in circuit (such as a deep freeze), you should not need to remove batteries for charging at all.  We have never had to do that on my 311,  which has 2 standard 'car batteries' for domestics,   and a small Red Flash starter.    The domestics drop to 11.3v occasionally when sailing,  but they come up fairly quickly again under charge.   The  starter battery never seems to go below 12v.

How old are your batteries? 

Regards   Fiddler
IP IP Logged
Raptor
Lieutenant Commander
Lieutenant Commander


Joined: 28 August 2009
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 66
Quote Raptor Replybullet Posted: 28 December 2009 at 22:30
The boat is a newbuilding from this summer, so you might say that the batteries are brand new. I have a small "car battery" for starting the engine and a large gel battery for domestics. I will measure using a voltmeter.
IP IP Logged
shaukaas
Captain
Captain
Avatar

Joined: 04 August 2008
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 168
Quote shaukaas Replybullet Posted: 29 December 2009 at 09:47

Both your battery banks will be charged from the generator when the engine is running. This is because of a charging relay/battery separator connecting both banks to the generator - when engine is running. (Basically just a relay closing.)

This introduces a new problem: IF, for an example, the domestic batteries are drained - the energy from the starter battery will be transferred to the domestic bank, until the voltage of both banks are even. Unless you have a "smart" battery seperator; I have replaced mine. The you have two half charged battery bank just within a few minutes. It will take you hours motoring to get them all the way back up to almost 100%.

Also, the generator is not able to produce enough voltage/amps to give a descent charging before the engine rpm is about 1000-1200 o/min. And even so, the "blind" voltage regulator on the Hitachi generator will give a charging voltage of 14,4V. By adding in a intelligent charge regulator, you can adjust the charging voltage/handling: Mine is boosting at 14,8V - and floating at 13,8V. (Open lead-acid batteries; have to refill water every now and then...)

In my 320 built in 2008, there is a Sterling Power battery charge mounted behind the back of the bench, in a small "hatch", on the port side - just to the right of the chart table. This have three separate outputs; one is used for the starter battery - one is used for the domestic bank. The third one is spare.

Also I would recommend to mount a Ah-meter, so you can keep track of your actual charge/power usage. At least it gave me a lot of new information when started using one.. For an example the fridge consumes about 40-60Ah a day; keeping in mindt that my 2x105Ah batteries gives me a 105Ah efficient discharge capacity - this device alone is almost enough to drain the batteries during a two day cruise. (Open lead-acid batteries should not be discharged more than 50% - that is the idea behind using a Ah-meter!)

This subject is complex, and if you're not especially interested in electronics; you should probably leave things as they are delivered from the yard - or get a skilled person to assist you. :)






Edited by shaukaas - 29 December 2009 at 09:52
S/Y Nadun - Hanse 320#171
LG3600 - NOR13510
IP IP Logged
Gran Onada
Commander
Commander


Joined: 14 November 2008
Location: Spain
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 89
Quote Gran Onada Replybullet Posted: 29 December 2009 at 10:44
Shaukaas,
 
As for your comments I think you are an expert on this matter, and may be you can answer my question.
 
I do have the same charger in my 350 and have 1 x 90 Amps (engine) + 2 x 110 Amp (service) Varta sealed lead-acid. Also have a Victron Energy battery monitor.
 
Output #1 is for the engine and outputs #2 and 3 are together for the service bank.
 
The situation is:
 
When service batteries bank is charged at 100%, the charger switches to the green led (float/powerpack), all devices need (fridge, lights, etc) are in use, then I can see at the battery monitor that service bank begins to dischage and voltage to drop (all this with the boat connected to shore), I've seen it as low as 76% and 11,80 Volts. So it seems like the charger is not charging or even keeping the battery level.
 
Then what I do is to unplug the boat from shore and plug it again (like doing a reset to the charger) and then it charges again.
 
Is this normal, or should I get in touch with the technical service?
 
I've seen in the manual that when  voltage drops to 11,50 Volts, charger does a resert and begins again. Should leave to go down to 11,50, and see what happends?
 
Thanks for your comments.
Gran Onada IV - Hanse 350 #130
IP IP Logged
fiddler
Sub Lieutenant
Sub Lieutenant
Avatar

Joined: 01 November 2007
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 18
Quote fiddler Replybullet Posted: 29 December 2009 at 10:59
Shaukaas is right,  unless it is a 'smart' charge regulator then one low battery will drain the other.   But don't all new builds have smart chargers?  Mine is a 1991 model and has a Calira Leadline charger which definitely keeps the 2 banks separate - I've often checked our voltages and woud go into panic mode if the starter battery started dropping.  It never has,  even when the domestics are way down near 11 volts.

One thing I also notice is that, when the charging starts,  the engine battery receives charge before the domestics for 15-20 minutes.  I think this deliberate,  but the instructions are in German which I cant translate.     Still, the voltmeter trick will reveal all.

Shaukass is also right that engine charging is not enough alone,  we do connect up at marinas 2-3 times a year to freshen things up.   All the same,  an hour of engine running at >1000rpm does the trick if we've been burning a lot.



IP IP Logged
shaukaas
Captain
Captain
Avatar

Joined: 04 August 2008
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 168
Quote shaukaas Replybullet Posted: 29 December 2009 at 17:28
Originally posted by Gran Onada

Shaukaas,
 
As for your comments I think you are an expert on this matter, and may be you can answer my question.
 
I do have the same charger in my 350 and have 1 x 90 Amps (engine) + 2 x 110 Amp (service) Varta sealed lead-acid. Also have a Victron Energy battery monitor.
 
Output #1 is for the engine and outputs #2 and 3 are together for the service bank.
 
The situation is:
 
When service batteries bank is charged at 100%, the charger switches to the green led (float/powerpack), all devices need (fridge, lights, etc) are in use, then I can see at the battery monitor that service bank begins to dischage and voltage to drop (all this with the boat connected to shore), I've seen it as low as 76% and 11,80 Volts. So it seems like the charger is not charging or even keeping the battery level.
 
Then what I do is to unplug the boat from shore and plug it again (like doing a reset to the charger) and then it charges again.
 
Is this normal, or should I get in touch with the technical service?
 


I'm not an official expert, but working as a service engineer in a company for automation technology for offshore equipment, I have some of the basic knowledge. The rest is from forums like these, manuals and technical handbooks/datasheets  - and, of course, off my keen interest... Embarrassed

If your charger is a Sterling Power; check the manual to verify that the jumper is set to sealed lead/acid batteries. I think this will give you a maximum charging voltage at 14.4V, and 13.8V float - whilst the open lead/acid will charge (boost) at 14.8V. As the sealed lead/acid batteries does not allow any water to be refilled - these are not suitable for "quick charging". The same rule is for AGM and Gel batteries.

The way your charger behaves is different from my Sterling Power CED1250 - which gives a steady 13.8V power supply at all times in float mode; and functions as a very stable powerpack being able to supply up to 50 Amps.

Please take into account that we have to different charging circuits here: A) Shore power and B) generator off the engine.

A) The Shore power battery charger (in my case) have three independent outputs. When this is turned on, the starter and the domestic bank will not be equalized. The outputs are separated by diodes, internally in the charger. A drawback with this charger, it that it is not able to independently control the three different battery banks - and can not charger different types of batteries at the same time. But in practical terms, I guess, this is not a common problem anyway...

B) Engine generator - charging voltage is controlled by a "blind" regulator at 14.4V on the original 60A Hitachi generator. The problem with this solution is that it is not very efficient; and it will take a lot of time/almost be impossible to charge your batteries all the way up to 100%. (The Ah-meter shows this clearly!)

To be able to isolate the starter battery from the domestic bank, a charging relay is normally fitted in between the generator and the batteries. In some cases they use manual switches, some a relay, others a transistor based system; maybe in some cases preventing the different battery banks from equalizing (discharging each other.) These transistor based devices will normally have up to a 0,6V voltage-drop across, so the maximum charging voltage on your batteries is 14,4V - 0,6V = 13,8V. This gives a horrible charging if it is the case.

One way to get around this, is to install a "smart" voltage regulator on the generator, with a voltage sensing on for an example the domestic bank. You will then charge your battery with 14,4V, as the voltage regulator always have control of your battery. Most of these also have a temperature sensor for your batteries, to avoid "cooking" the battery - but also to compensate the charging voltage according to the temperature.

The problem then, however, is with two or more battery banks... 
If the charge current to the domestic bank is fairly high and you have a voltage drop across the battery cables; you run the risk of overcharging your start battery. If the start battery is a open lead/acid, this can normally be dealt with by checking the water level occasionally - and refilling when needed.

What I did to be on the "absolute sure-safe" side; is to install a smart voltage regulator sensing the voltage on a intelligent battery separator. This is software controlled, and have a only a neglectable voltage drop. It also assures that the different battery banks get the sufficient charging - avoids overcharging and equalizing/discharging.

And also, of course, the Ah-meter which gives me the full picture of the battery and charging condition! (Generator voltage, generator amps, start battery voltage, domestic battery voltage and Ah-meter.)

The cost of installing this is certainly moderate; but taking into account the total of money and effort being spent on the boat - I find it satisfactory to have a perfectly working charging system; and not have to worry about charging problems in the near future. My only concern is to refill water on my batteries...

The main reason for me to install this, was a "lack of juice" when using the original installation. Just by using the electrical anchor-winch to set the anchor for the weekend; my batteries where almost totally drained... This can be explained by a generator not charging much at idle speed - and me using the anchor winch when idling. Combined with a lot of sailing, a fridge full of beer, stereo and navigation electronics the 6-7 hours before anchoring - showed the weak sides of the original charging system.

If you're able to hook up to the grid every evening, the need for this is not existing. But I preffer to be at anchor, away from the crowded places - being capable of a long distance cruise without running the engine.


S/Y Nadun - Hanse 320#171
LG3600 - NOR13510
IP IP Logged
Windsurfer
Captain
Captain


Joined: 07 April 2010
Location: Russian Federation
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 190
Quote Windsurfer Replybullet Posted: 27 July 2010 at 01:43
Shaukaas...I know it will take a while coz you're probably sailing again Wink
but when possible could you post some pictures of your mentioned above electrical upgrades...I've got a Sterling charger as well and hate to see one of the batteries boiling like a geyser while the other one is still charging at max...
there's another issue...while the shore cable is connected I actually see the 2 boiling batteries...the pannel shows that they're fully charged (when I turn off the charger)...I turn the charger inline and see it go to the boost mode again...the red light is always on....Do you have any idea why it doesn't float??? The batteries are open lead/acid so it appears that I shouldn't cut the wire, but topping up the batteries all the time wouldn't help I guess - they will die sooner or later if I don't change something dramatically...
Hanse 320 #079
IP IP Logged
nickfabbri
Commander
Commander


Joined: 21 April 2008
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 120
Quote nickfabbri Replybullet Posted: 27 July 2010 at 07:58
When the red light is on , the charger is in float mode. When the red and green lights are on , the charger is charging. The manual for the charger should be available online.
Incidentally, I have also always struggled to understand the led lights for the battery charge state. After 3 seasons of worrying about the battery charge I have left have stopped worrying . So far ( touch wood) I have no problems with the batteries. I checked te electrolyte levels for the first time last week and they were fine.

However my theory on the battery lights is as follows: there are 5 bars for each of the 2 banks. You only get five bars when the batteries are full and have zero drain, or are charging. This is the only tme I ever get five bars.
The other 4 bars represent 25% increments in charge state. I base this on the fact that my invertor has similar led lights. When I have 4 bars on my switch panel, the invertor shows 100% charge, 3 bars on the panel; 75% charge on the invertor and so on.

On a final note, when I had the boat delivered, the charger had a loose connection and would not charge. Hanse tightened everything and it worked fine. Also apparently occasionally the Stirling chargers break. Their customer service is meant to be amazing , but if you have a red float light on I guess it's all working .
Hope this helps
Nick71
IP IP Logged
Andrew
Sub Lieutenant
Sub Lieutenant
Avatar

Joined: 20 October 2007
Location: Germany
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 14
Quote Andrew Replybullet Posted: 27 July 2010 at 08:09
Just get back to basics and away from smart chargers. The engine battery should be disconnected from the domestic when sailing and connected to the domestic when charging either from engine or shore power. before I invested in a sterling DC to DC charger. I had a relay (big one) which was activated by the "F" terminal on the alternator. That is the one which turns on or off the light when the key is on but the engine not running. If the charger is connected to both batterys then both will charge at the same time and the one which is low will take more charge. There should be no voltage leakage when the charger is off. If this is the case then the engine battery is dischrging through the charger to the domestic.
 
All that said I recomend investing in a Sterling smart charging system. but with this system you can not mix gel domestic batterys with lead/acid engine battery.
 
Andrew
IP IP Logged
Page  of 2 Next >>
Post Reply Post New Topic
Printable version Printable version

Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum



This page was generated in 0.242 seconds.

Links : www.hanseyachts.co.uk www.hanseyachts.com www.fjordboats.co.uk www.hansedownunder.com.au www.cobaltboatsuk.com